The Fall of the Roman Empire

There’s something unnerving in watching Anthony Mann’s The Fall of the Roman Empire (1964) as 2017 draws to a close. Its arc of corruption, cruelty, and decadence eroding political institutions until the greatest political office in the land is merely a prize to be auctioned off to the highest bidder feels frighteningly contemporary, an apocalypse for our times. 

The Fall of the Roman Empire marked a different kind of apocalypse in 1964, when it served as the harbinger of the end of the classic Hollywood epic. This expensive folly effectively ended the career of producer Samuel Bronston (who produced King of Kings, El Cid, and 55 Days to Peking), and like Joseph Mankiewicz’s troubled Cleopatra (which was released only a year earlier), Fall offers stunning example of excess as spectacle.

Mann, working in collaboration with cinematographer Robert Krasker and production designers John Moore and Vemiero Colasanti, crafts a film that is simply too huge to be believed (it holds the record for the largest film set ever created: a sprawling replica of the Roman Forum). But Fall‘s tableaus are more than grand. Mann stages the film as a series of dynamic and expressive tableaus, with a sophisticated sense of character position. He transforms a bedroom conversation between the ailing Marcus Aurelius (invested with considerable gravitas by the great Alec Guinness) and his daughter Lucilla (Sophia Loren, as radiant as ever, if somewhat hamstrung by the script) into a beautifully expressive sequence of poses that articulating the complexity of their relationship and its power imbalances.

Fall is admittedly not always so artful. Mann’s careful direction cannot entirely overcome an undernourished, albeit well-structured, melodrama acted out by a wooden heroic lead. Stephen Boyd, as the blonde Livius, fails to elevate the stock material he is given, and as such the film tends to stall in swaths of its second half, when he becomes a major driving force for the narrative (otherwise, the film feels more like an ensemble piece, with James Mason and Christopher Plummer delivering particularly fine work). Some flourishes, such as two attempts to give characters internal dialogue via voiceover, feel strained and silly. Other sequences feel like gratuitous plays to audience expectation, like a chariot race lifted from Ben Hur (which, admittedly, does boast some great stuntwork).

Still, the film’s clear sense of trajectory and and its vibrant images make it altogether much more compelling than its more simple-minded remake, Ridley Scott’s Gladiator, which borrows Fall‘s narrative beats but none of its convictions. Indeed, The Fall of the Roman Empire is, like many of the classic Hollywood epics, a close cousin to opera, both in structural design and in its emphasis on music. The first thing to make an impression in The Fall of the Roman Empire is the unforgettable overture for Dimitri Tiomkin’s maximalist score, a work of accomplished bombast that mingles orchestra and harpsichord and pipe organ and choir.

I have long suspected that a viewer’s emotional admiration of the classic Hollywood epics will correlate closely to their attentiveness and receptiveness to the films’ musical scores, which, in the classic Hollywood epics, do not function as mere window dressing, but as a pillar on which the film rests. In these stately films, the (often stilted) quasi-Shakespearean dialogue functions like a spoken libretto to the more passionate, vital underscore. If Tiomkin’s score is not as complex as some of its peers (like Alex North’s rich, precise work on Spartacus and Cleopatra), it nevertheless provides the clearest articulation of the film’s dramatic impulses.

6 Replies to “The Fall of the Roman Empire”

  1. One thing Gladiator has way over on Fall of the Roman Empire is its hero. Where Boyd takes a bland character and makes him blander, Russell Crowe digs into Maximus with tremendous charisma and emotional intensity. Gladiator may not be as complex or intelligent as Fall, but it’s a helluva lot more fun, thanks especially to Crowe.
    Still, Fall remains an impressive and thoughtful film that really does deserve more attention than it gets. (I’d also put Tiomkin’s score well above those two North scores, personally)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Crowe is certainly much more charismatic than Boyd, no argument there. It’s a shame that Charlton Heston turned down Boyd’s part. It might be a thankless role, but his natural gravitas would have anchored the film.

      Alex North’s scores are structurally, thematically, and harmonically more complex than Tiomkin’s work here. I can spend (and have spent) hours teasing apart the layers of North’s work. Also, I’m not sure that any of Tiomkin’s cues are ever as emotionally bracing as North’s “Goodbye My Life, My Love,” which might be the second-greatest film cue of all time (behind Herrmann’s “Scene d’Amour,” naturally).

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I am a huge Stephen Boyd fan (www.stephenboydblog.com), and although this may not be his best work it still ranks as my favorite movie of all time. No one has ever looked better in a Roman helmet than Boyd! It is a totally different movie from Gladiator except the beginning….while Gladiator is like an old peplum flick, FOTRE is much darker and cloudy in its presentation. I can’t imagine anyone other than Boyd as Livius myself. Yes, Crowe as Maximus is riveting and worthy of the Oscar he received. Livius is basically a passive and sonewhat powerless observer to the downfall which surrounds him, which in my opinion makes this an interesting character. But then again, I could watch Stephen Boyd read a dictionary and be thrilled since I am a fan of his work! I sure wish an extended blu ray with the edited German barbarian scenes would be released someday. Thanks for posting this! I will reblog it! 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Great post! TFOTRE is an outstanding epic, i love Gladiator too but prefer this film. I think all the performances in it are very good, Boyd included. Plummer of course gets the juiciest role as the somewhat unhinged Commodus.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s